MARK GOUDIE
← All insights

Identity / MARK GOUDIE

Removing false identities

You can be close to someone and still feel unknown. How much of you is present when keeping the connection means hiding your experience?

Being known for the person who copes

You can be close to someone and still feel unknown. They know the person who keeps going. The person who says everything is fine. The person who knows what everyone else needs.

But what happens when that isn’t how you feel? If keeping the connection means hiding your experience, how much of you is actually in it?

We might call this a false identity, but that can sound as though we deliberately set out to deceive people. Often we learnt a way of being that helped us belong. Being useful brought approval. Being agreeable avoided conflict. Being capable meant nobody needed to worry about us.

When a role becomes a requirement

There is nothing wrong with being capable or generous. The difficulty begins when those descriptions stop allowing any other experience. If I’m the strong one, where does my fear go? If I’m the easygoing one, how do I say that something hurts?

You agree to help again, although you’re already stretched. Later you feel resentful that nobody noticed. But what information did they have? You said yes. You smiled. The part of you that needed something else never entered the conversation.

Other people may have expectations of you. Some may resist your boundaries. There are also expectations you keep enforcing yourself, long after anyone has asked you to meet them. It helps to look at both.

Honesty starts before disclosure

Before telling someone what you feel, you may need to recognise it yourself. What do I actually want? What am I agreeing to because I’m afraid of the response? Which parts of my experience do I immediately explain away?

There is no requirement to share everything with everyone. Privacy belongs here too. Being honest with yourself doesn’t mean making yourself vulnerable to someone who repeatedly uses that vulnerability against you.

With someone you trust, the beginning can be small. I said I was okay, but I’m finding this difficult. I want to help, but I can’t do that this week. I don’t know what I need yet, and I’d like some time to understand it.

More room to be human

We can turn authenticity into another performance. Now we have to be perfectly open, certain of our needs and unafraid of judgement. It becomes another version of ourselves to maintain.

What if there is no finished identity to uncover? You can be capable and need help. Love someone and disagree with them. Be generous and have limits. None of those experiences removes the others.

The question is whether the descriptions you live by leave room for the person having this experience today. What haven’t you allowed yourself to acknowledge because it doesn’t fit who you’re supposed to be?